
Love was in the air on Wednesday, February 9, 2011, at a moderated panel discussion convened by the
Center on Philanthropy and Civil Society at the Graduate Center of The City University of New York.
Kudos to Kathleen D. McCarthy, professor of History and director of the Center on Philanthropy and Civil Society, for bringing together a panel of New York hedge fund experts who provided views on what makes the partnership between hedge funds and philanthropy an exciting relationship.
Besides providing unique first-person insights into hedge fund managers and their brand of philanthropy, the panel provided insider tips into the psyche of the hedge fund manager. Two of panelists made it a point to refer to themselves as marathon runners. (Note: Last month you were advised in "Getting Fit to Fundraise" to use the library as your philanthropy fitness center.)
Joan Werner, former director, Marketing and Client Services at Ramius LLC, now serves as treasurer of 100 Women in Hedge Funds, a global association of alternative investments professionals who work to make a difference in the industry and their communities via mentoring, educational programming, and fundraising for specific causes. John Budzyna, chief executive officer, Cutting Hedge Consulting, is also chairman and co-founder of Hedge Funds Care, a worldwide charity focused on the prevention and treatment of child abuse. Lisa Utasi, director and senior equity trader, ClearBridge Advisors, co-chaired the Muscular Dystrophy Association's Wings Over Wall Street Fund Raising Committee for two years. Utasi was the 2007 Michael P. Beier Award Recipient for her dedication to raising funding for ALS.
Is philanthropy a natural activity of the hedge fund industry?
Comparisons between George Soros and Gordon Gekko were raised, and reference was made to Andrew Carnegie. Panelists were asked what makes hedge fund managers give, and how hedge fund philanthropy is different from the philanthropy practiced by private foundations.
Hedge fund managers are highly organized and analytical, sales oriented, and always interested in outcomes. As donors, they always want to know where the money will go, and how it will be used. Few donors in this field will be comfortable knowing their money is going to administrative costs and overhead. The ability to ignite individual passions, hopefully for your cause, is vital. At first glance, fundraising meets the hedge fund professionals need to network and do business. On a deeper level, philanthropy meets a human need to give back to society.
We learned hedge fund managers are good at organizing and attending special events. They enjoy the opportunity to come out and network with people they know in business. Having a name attached to an event is a surefire way to attract attention; honoring high profile individuals who interact with hedge fund industry professionals, including their lawyers, accountants, and analysts, was the common advice from the panel. Make sure the honoree is philanthropic, so he/she can encourage others to give. (You might try using the library's prospecting databases, including our Celebrity Directory to identify high profile hedge fund types who have their own private foundations.)
For some hedge fund professionals, the philanthropic instinct is discovered by accident and/or because someone asked them to participate. First there is commitment, and then comes a focus on due diligence and ensuring the money spent goes to programs, not overhead.
Two out of the three speakers discovered philanthropy by accident. John Budzyna, a marathoner, was invited to participate during a training run in Central Park. Once he discovered he could fundraise, the passion for the field grew. Due diligence and responsibility to the company's benefit, however, go hand in hand with that commitment; we were advised hedge fund professionals will ask whether their relationship with your cause or organization is good for their companies, and they will carefully scrutinize your finances.
Joan Werner described how 100 Women in Hedge Funds was founded by three women working in an industry dominated by men. The women saw a need to network, mentor, and educate other hedge fund women. Their 10,000 members feel strongly about helping their membership and helping society. Werner spoke about how she got caught up in fundraising. She showed up a meeting with 10 people in a room; she didn't join the group but soon would. The next day Werner was called upon to organize a fundraiser for breast cancer because of her sales experience. She quickly discovered her professional networking skills made her a natural at setting up fundraising events. The work was fun. Werner's members feel fundraising is a bonding opportunity that transcends the business side of their work.
100 Women in Hedge Funds is also quite focused on how grantees use the funds and requests several financial statements. If you can't use their money in the first year, they will hold on to it. 100 Women in Hedge Funds has relationship managers who stay in touch with recipients to monitor the grant money.
John Budzyna described how Hedge Funds Care picked child abuse as their cause. Child abuse occurs in all types of families and communities. He explained that even if poverty were to disappear from the world, child abuse would still continue to be a problem in society. Budzyna was hooked on the cause after his mentor took him on a site visit.
As far as organizational practices, the fundraising committee insists new committee members spend time visiting grant recipients. The organization also has an academic advisor in each city of operation who answers questions on how to allocate their money.
Lisa Utasi said traders give to ALS-related organizations because they know colleagues who are directly affected by this disease. "Once they see a need, they want to solve it." Utasi also focused on the skills that set hedge fund professionals apart in the philanthropic sector, and her instinct, like that of her fellow traders, is to determine whether a grantee organization is run in a business-like manner.
The skeptic in Dr. McCarthy prompted her to ask, "Does a show of philanthropy create loyalty in investors? Is there a business payoff to philanthropy?"
Joan Werner focused on philanthropy creating a bond – working together for the greater good, but she also said there was a payoff, both human and in the loyalty of customers, to her organization. Fundraising is a bonding activity for her membership. Werner believes fundraising can transcend the business side of your work.
John Budzyna concurred with Werner on building loyalty. Companies approach his group to co-brand an event. They pair a firm with a charity. Their database of hedge fund professionals has expanded to include a network of individuals working within the industry, including accountants, brokers, and information technology specialists.
Lisa Utasi focuses on a message, "You (your firm) will do well by doing good." She and Budzyna advise keeping the charitable side of your work separate from the business side. 100 Women in Hedge Funds stays away from issues or personalities with political or religious connections. The advice is to pick neutral organizations to support.
Two out of the three philanthropic organizations represented on this panel use public relations firms to communicate about their missions and events. There was consensus that not enough of the broader public understands how much individuals in the hedge fund industry give back to society. Budzyna is convinced that in 20 years we will read about the rise of the hedge fund managers in giving back.
Do hedge fund managers create their own nonprofit organizations?
Joan Werner has formed two nonprofits in addition to her work with 100 Women in Hedge Funds. Lisa Utasi says once you are part of something that is philanthropic it grows within you. Her commitment is now to microfinance and women. She's started five organizations to do work in this field. Budzyna says people come to Hedge Funds Care to replicate it in their communities. Budzyna said, "plenty of people out there want to make a difference."
This was an information panel discussion, and we look forward to the next session of the Leaders in Philanthropy lecture series.
-- Susan Shiroma, Senior Librarian
Recent Comments